Clicking "Submit" opens a pre-filled GitHub Issue in a new tab. You'll need a free GitHub account to post. This connects your feedback to the public record of this proposal.
GitHub Issue URL (preview)
—
Examples of useful feedback
Challenge
Performance-Weighted Formula violates Article 81
Article 81 requires constituency sizes to be "as nearly as may be equal." The 15% growth floor creates constituencies with meaningfully different population sizes — UP at 2.9M vs TN at 1.9M. This should require explicit constitutional amendment language overriding Article 81, not just relying on Articles 14 and 38.
Improvement
Whip prohibition needs constitutional backing, not just Rules of Procedure
The 8 federal subjects are protected by Rules of Procedure which can be reversed by a future Rajya Sabha majority. The Belgium model — where coalition parity is constitutionally mandated — suggests these protections need constitutional text to be durable. Suggest embedding at least the Finance Commission and President's Rule subjects directly in Article 118.
Question
What happens if a Revenue Zone has no eligible technocrat?
Article 74-A requires zone CMs to confirm the technocrat minister within 30 days. What if CMs don't confirm? What if there's a dispute about who qualifies as a "technocrat"? The fallback mechanism isn't specified.